c/o Steve McLaughlin

Wesleyan Football Wins Third Consecutive NESCAC Championship, First NCAA Tournament Bid 

Few weekends have been as momentous for the Wesleyan Football program as the weekend of Nov. 14, 2026. 

On Saturday, the Red and Black captured their third straight NESCAC championship. The following day, they were awarded an NCAA bid for the first time in program history. 

Led by head coach Dan DiCenzo, the Cards have been dominant in a way unprecedented in Wesleyan history. DiCenzo reflected on his expectations for the season.

“We have high standards for our program, and thought we were good enough to compete for a conference championship again,” DiCenzo said. 

The weekend started in Hartford, Conn., against NESCAC foe the Trinity College Bantams. Coming into the weekend the Bantams had a perfect 8–0 record, while the Cards were 7–1, with their only loss going to Amherst.

“We had [a] hiccup at Amherst,” DiCenzo said. “I give Amherst a lot of credit, they won a lot of close games this year.”

If Wesleyan beat Trinity, there would be a three-way tie between the Bantams, Cards, and Mammoths. However, a loss would shatter their dreams of NCAA tournament play. 

Yet, for the Red and Black, making the NCAA tournament was secondary. For the team guys, this was seen as another weekend, another chance to go 1–0.

“We were confident going into the game,” Linebacker and Captain Austin Baker ’27 said. “Obviously, it was a big game. We knew it was a big game.”

The rivalry with Trinity is one of the best in NESCAC football with the Bantams holding the overall record of 57–67. Yet, the Cards had won the previous two match-ups heading into the weekend. Wide receiver Donte Kelly ’29 knew the team was confident heading into the game.

“We know we’re a better team,” Kelly said. “We all hold each other accountable and that’s what makes us so great.”

After scoreless drives from both teams to open the game, the Bantams, starting on Wesleyan’s 34-yard, line manufactured an easy five-play touchdown drive.

“They made a play, and our job [is to] adjust afterwards,” Baker said. “Everyone adjusts. We adjusted our scheme.”

The offense answered back immediately, shrinking the deficit with a field goal. Quarterback and Captain Matt Fitzsimons ’27 reflected on the offense’s start to the game and what jumpstarted the offense. 

“We definitely started off a little shaky,” Fitzsimons said. “We [were] playing in a very hostile environment and it just definitely took us a little bit to settle in. But one key play that stood out was on our [second] drive. The first play was a sack, and then on second down, Angelo LaRose [’27] ran for [66] yards. That definitely helped us settle down.”

The Bantams added a field goal on their following drive. However, the defensive adjustments paid off on Trinity’s next drive as they stopped at Wesleyan’s 44-yard line. Trinity attempted a fake punt but Warren Little ’27 and Tommy Dayton ’29 thwarted their attempt.

“They usually try to fake a punt for whatever reason every year against us, so we were definitely ready for it,” DiCenzo said.

The Cards took advantage of their good field position as they made it to Trinity’s 15-yard line, but Trinity was able to once again stop Wesleyan in the red zone. The Red and Black kicked another field goal, leaving the Bantams with a 10–6 lead with 2:04 left in the first half. 

The defense had another crucial moment on the Bantams’ first play of the drive when Baker and Tommy Kilroy ’29 combined for a fumble and recovery. Baker reflected on the moment.

“One of the things our defense does a great job of is pursuit,” Baker said. “Tommy ended up punching it out, and I was in the spot so I just jumped on it. It was a big moment in the game.”

The Cardinals’ offense once again took advantage, as Fitzsimons found Jake Saalfrank ’29 for 40 yards. Then, despite nursing an injury, Fitzsimons performed a 1-yard touchdown run a few plays later.

“I knew going into the game once we especially got in those red zone situations that I was gonna have to take advantage of them thinking that I was hurt,” Fitzsimons said. “Even though I was hurt, I still made the right play by running, and I knew I was going to have to do things like that. So, being able to do that felt great, and scoring right before the half was awesome.”

Going into half, the Red and Black were up 13–10 with a lot of work to be done on both sides of the ball. 

Kelly reflected on the attitude in the locker room and amongst the offense.

“We just said it’s 0–0,” he said. “We told ourselves that we want to pick it up and show that we’re a true offense. We’re one of the best offenses in the league, but there were still a lot of mistakes, and that’s why we’re here to fix them.” 

That they did, as the second half saw the offense come alive. In the third quarter, Fitzsimons found Kelly for the offense’s first passing touchdown of the game.

“I feel like it gave us a boost,” Kelly said about the moment. “It showed us that even though we’re making a lot of mistakes, this team can’t hang with us. They’re a great team, but we felt like we [were] the better team, and we proved that. Matthew Fitzsimons is a great quarterback. So if I’m open, I know he’s gonna see me.”

The Kelly-Fitzsimons connection showed up again in a crucial moment during the fourth quarter when a deep ball brought Wesleyan up 27–10 with 8:40 to go.

“It was a really exciting moment. I was really amped up, but I obviously wouldn’t do it without Matthew and the O-line. The coaches called a great play. It was man to man, and I just knew I had to catch it,” Kelly said.

Such a dominant second-half offense doesn’t happen by chance. Kelly described the work it takes to get to that moment.

“When the defense [was] out there, we all sat on the bench and talked and watched film and we just started to notice things and change the game plan,” he said.

Trinity crawled back into the game, making it 27–20, with 1:32 left. The Bantams would get one more shot with 1:14 on the clock after Fitzsimons threw an interception. 

Baker reflected on the defense coming back onto the field at that moment.

“Our [defensive coordinator] was like ‘hey, they got one option here, and that’s to go deep. So let the underneath happen,’” Baker said. “The strength of our defense is tackling. So we trusted that, we trusted our [defensive backs] to go deep. They had a new quarterback in there, so we felt confident that if we got some pressure on him, it wasn’t going to be as accurate. He tucked it down and ran it and then they were able to get one last play off. It was a hail mary. But our defense did a great job and came out with the win.” 

Fitzsimons spoke about the special nature of the Cardinals’ third consecutive NESCAC championship. 

“It felt great. I mean, there’s no better feeling for sure,” Fitzsimons said. “I’m so proud to be a captain on this team and just lead, lead our team to victory like this. And it’s just, definitely a special moment to see everything we talked about, everything we preach come come to fruition like it did on Saturday.”

With the Cards coming away with a win, there was officially a three way tie between the Bantams, Cards, and Mammoths, and after exhausting all previously established tie-breaker methods, they were left with a coin flip. Trinity ended up winning, meaning that they would get the automatic qualifier and Wesleyan would be at the mercy of an at-large bid. With the tournament being 40 teams, with 11 at-large bids, the Cardinals were hoping to be one of the lucky ones. 

Coach DiCenzo reflected the Cards’ odds of making the NCAA tournament after losing the coin flip.

“Before the coin flip, we knew that our [NCAA Power Index (NPI)] was higher than Trinity’s and Amherst’s,” DiCenzo said. “We had more away games, and our loss was on the road. Both of their losses were at home, so we had higher points. We knew that if we beat Trinity, that our NPI would be higher than theirs. So the coin flip didn’t really matter. We knew we were already in the playoffs. We were just hoping we would get the bye.”

While the coin flip didn’t stop the Cardinals or Amherst from making the NCAA tournament, DiCenzo noted that they had to “come up with a better system than that.”

The Cardinals got their name called for the NCAA tournament and got a bye along with their berth. 

Baker reflected on hearing the Cardinals’ name called.

“It was a fun experience to hear our name called and looking forward to the opportunity to keep playing,” Baker said. “That’s what I’m most excited about, is we get the opportunity to play more than nine games.” 

Kelly said it was an “honor to represent Wesleyan as one of the first NESCAC schools to be in the Division III playoffs.” 

Fitzsimons said finding out they had a bye was “even better…it was just another moment of proudness and greatness for this team to kind of see that happen.”

Many outside of the NESCAC weren’t happy to see three teams represented in the NCAA. DiCenzo remarked on three teams making NCAA and what needs to change in order to stop the discourse.

“I think our league is very good, we will represent really well,” DiCenzo said. “I hate to say it, but I’m rooting for Trinity and Amherst this weekend. We want our league to do well, but I think everyone in the country has a right to feel that we should not have three in because we don’t play out of conference. So my concern is if we don’t make that change, they might try to ban us if we don’t play out-of-conference games. We need to make that simple change for next year, so we’re in better shape that way.”

While the Cardinals have high expectations for the rest of the season and hopes for a four-peat, DiCenzo reflected on their multi-year stampede through the NESCAC.

“It’s been a fun three-year run,” DiCenzo said. “And again, I think this team’s got more left in it to still show for the season. So we’re excited about that, and our team is kind of built to be one of the top teams [here] for years to come. So we’re definitely excited about where we’re at.”

The Cardinals aren’t done just yet: They head to face off against Springfield College at 12:00 p.m. on Saturday, Nov. 28.

“I think we’re gonna treat it like any other game,” Fitzsimons said. “We know they’re really good. It’s gonna be tough going on the road. We’re gonna do the best we can preparing these next week and a half practicing, which is nice that we get an extra week and a half for the bye. But we’re gonna be ready. We know they’re a really good team. There’s a reason why we have to go play them at their home field, but we’re gonna be ready to go.”

Shikhar Gupta contributed reporting and can be reached at sgupta01@wesleyan.edu.

Leila Feldman can be reached at lfeldman01@wesleyan.edu.

Benjamin Mayer can be reached at bmayer@wesleyan.edu. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *